THE 4PM POLL: Which Supreme Court Justice Overturned Roe Best? In overturning Roe v. Wade Friday, the six conservative Supreme Court justices handed down a total of four different opinions. Which conservative Supreme Court justice issued the best anti-Roe opinion? SAMUEL ALITO: The federal right to an abortion had to go, but that doesn’t mean contraception and same-sex marriage are next. CHIEF JUSTICE JOHN ROBERTS: The court went too far and shouldn’t have overturned the Roe regime entirely. CLARENCE THOMAS: The court should go further and reconsider the rights to contraception and sex-sex marriage. BRETT KAVANAUGH: The court went just far enough, and lawmakers shouldn’t get carried away, like by banning abortions in other states. Have more to say about this? Email us at [email protected], and we may publish your response.